Crime & Safety
Livingston County, NY Woman Faces Felony After Parking Lot Incident
Geneseo, NY – A 23 year old Livingston County woman is facing felony and misdemeanor charges following an alleged domestic dispute in a Geneseo business parking lot that investigators say resulted in
By Tessa Morgan · 2026-11-16T17:56:39.993Z
Geneseo, NY – A 23 year old Livingston County woman is facing felony and misdemeanor charges following an alleged domestic dispute in a Geneseo business parking lot that investigators say resulted in intentional damage to a man's vehicle.
According to the Livingston County Sheriff 's Office, deputies responded to a business on East South Street in the village of Geneseo around 11:39 a.m. Thursday, November 12, following reports of a domestic incident involving property damage.
Woman Accused of Damaging Vehicle During Dispute Investigators allege that 23 year old Hillary Shaw of Mt. Morris became involved in a domestic dispute with a male individual.
During the confrontation, Shaw allegedly intentionally damaged the man's vehicle, according to Sheriff Thomas J. Dougherty.
Following an investigation, Deputy Ryan Damboise arrested Shaw on Sunday, November 15.
She was charged with third degree criminal mischief, a felony, and second degree reckless endangerment, a misdemeanor.
The sheriff's office did not specify the extent of the vehicle damage or provide additional details about the alleged reckless endangerment.
Suspect Released Following Court Arraignment Following her arrest, Shaw was transported to the Livingston County Jail, where she was turned over to Central Booking deputies for processing and pre arraignment detention.
She later appeared before Town of Leicester Justice Durbin at the Livingston County Centralized Arraignment Part.
According to the sheriff's office, Shaw was released on her own recognizance because the charges did not qualify for bail under New York state's bail reform provisions.
The Livingston County Public Defender's Office represented Shaw during the proceeding, while the Livingston County District Attorney's Office appeared on behalf of the prosecution.
Authorities announced the arrest Monday, November 16.
No additional court dates or case developments were provided in the sheriff's release.
The charges are allegations, and Shaw is presumed innocent unless proven guilty in court.