Crime & Safety
Indiana Fraud Alert: $2.4M Restitution Ordered in Elder Scam
CARMEL, IN — An international fraud investigation involving elderly victims across multiple states has resulted in an eight year federal prison sentence, with a Carmel, Indiana, detective playing a le
By Claire Benton · 2026-11-16T19:41:53.111Z
CARMEL, IN — An international fraud investigation involving elderly victims across multiple states has resulted in an eight year federal prison sentence, with a Carmel, Indiana, detective playing a leading role in uncovering the operation.
According to the City of Carmel, Ahmed Maqbul Syed, 60, was sentenced Oct. 27 to 96 months in federal prison for conspiracy to commit money laundering. He was also ordered to pay approximately $2.4 million in restitution to victims.
The nearly three year investigation involved the Carmel Police Department , FBI and law enforcement agencies nationwide.
The case began in November 2023 after a Westfield resident lost $80,000 in gold to someone impersonating an FBI agent. Carmel Police Detective Mike Morley helped coordinate an undercover operation that led to an arrest.
In February 2024, a Carmel resident was similarly deceived into surrendering $48,000 in cash to a fake federal agent.
That victim photographed the suspect's vehicle and license plate, providing investigators with evidence that eventually connected the cases to Syed.
Morley, working alongside FBI Special Agent Allyson Kalscheuer, helped lead the investigation. He participated in or advised approximately a dozen undercover operations across several states and assisted with search warrants.
Investigators uncovered an international criminal network that allegedly used fraudulent computer pop ups, telephone calls and impersonation of law enforcement officers to convince older Americans to surrender cash, gold and other valuables.
"International organized crime groups are investing heavily in fraud schemes targeting older adults in the United States," Morley said.
Carmel Mayor Sue Finkam praised the cooperation between local and federal investigators.
Authorities warn that legitimate law enforcement officers will never demand cash, gold, gift cards or cryptocurrency to protect someone's assets.
Residents receiving suspicious requests should immediately stop communicating with the caller and contact law enforcement through independently verified phone numbers.